adiaforon

Not essential to the faith

When the past is prologue

English: German philosopher Theodor Adorno

As a philosophy major, I read many texts that were written in the past — some long ago.  Of course, I came upon Marx and then what was called Marxism (though Marx wouldn’t have applied this term to himself).  Then, came the 20th century versions of “Marxism,” some of which laid the groundwork of what some ‘spherians have bitterly described as “cultural Marxism.” I don’t disagree with their diatribes, but I do get rankled now and again when they want to tar Marxists with a wide brush.  They always sound to me like they’re quite ignorant of some offshoots and smaller branches of the field.

Read the following quote and tell me how applicable this is to today:

Culture is a paradoxical commodity. So completely is it subject to the law of exchange that it is no longer exchanged; it is so blindly consumed in use that it can no longer be used. Therefore it amalgamates with advertising. The more meaningless the latter seems to be under a monopoly, the more omnipotent it becomes. The motives are markedly economic. One could certainly live without the culture industry, therefore it necessarily creates too much satiation and apathy. In itself, it has few resources itself to correct this. Advertising is its elixir of life. But as its product never fails to reduce to a mere promise the enjoyment which it promises as a commodity, it eventually coincides with publicity, which it needs because it cannot be enjoyed. In a competitive society, advertising performed the social service of informing the buyer about the market; it made choice easier and helped the unknown but more efficient supplier to dispose of his goods. Far from costing time, it saved it. Today, when the free market is coming to an end, those who control the system are entrenching themselves in it. It strengthens the firm bond between the consumers and the big combines.

Only those who can pay the exorbitant rates charged by the advertising agencies, chief of which are the radio networks themselves; that is, only those who are already in a position to do so, or are co-opted by the decision of the banks and industrial capital, can enter the pseudo-market as sellers. The costs of advertising, which finally flow back into the pockets of the combines, make it unnecessary to defeat unwelcome outsiders by laborious competition. They guarantee that power will remain in the same hands — not unlike those economic decisions by which the establishment and running of undertakings is controlled in a totalitarian state. Advertising today is a negative principle, a blocking device: everything that does not bear its stamp is economically suspect. Universal publicity is in no way necessary for people to get to know the kinds of goods — whose supply is restricted anyway. It helps sales only indirectly. For a particular firm, to phase out a current advertising practice constitutes a loss of prestige, and a breach of the discipline imposed by the influential clique on its members. In wartime, goods which are unobtainable are still advertised, merely to keep industrial power in view. Subsidizing ideological media is more important than the repetition of the name.

The quote is from the book Dialectic of Enlightenment, by Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno, two of the founders of the Frankfurt School in pre- and post-war Germany.  During World War II, both spent some time here in the US in California, where they witnessed the rise of the “culture industry” and mass-market advertising.  Their words are prescient and very applicable today, though you can replace the radio with the Net and the ever-encroaching efforts to commercialize it further.  (Fortunately, there’s no mass government control — yet.)

The book is well worth a read, but will require patience since the language is a bit of a slog and the material might presuppose a lot.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Advertisements

5 responses to “When the past is prologue

  1. Tia April 22, 2013 at 4:11 pm

    “As a philosophy major, I read many texts that were written in the past — some long ago. Of course, I came upon Marx and then what was called Marxism (though Marx wouldn’t have applied this term to himself). Then, came the 20th century versions of “Marxism,” some of which laid the groundwork of what some ‘spherians have bitterly described as “cultural Marxism.” I don’t disagree with their diatribes, but I do get rankled now and again when they want to tar Marxists with a wide brush. They always sound to me like they’re quite ignorant of some offshoots and smaller branches of the field”

    The irony is that the Manospherians themselves are nothing more than a bunch of Sexual Marxists:

    “From each according her ability, to each according his need”

    Because they are unable or unwilling to compete in an open sexual market.

  2. Tia April 24, 2013 at 11:41 am

    Its open. Unless you mean competition makes it closed.

    Like I said, the Sexual Marxists of the Manosphere are unable to compete, thus why they oppose it.

  3. Tia April 24, 2013 at 1:16 pm

    And I almost forget. The reason why racism and white nationalism rears its head so frequently in the Manosphere also reflects their inability to compete with non-white males for the attention of white females.

    A few well known M-sphere bloggers actually said they lie in bed at night losing sleep over the fact that white women are now mating with non-white males.

    Classical Freudian Penis Envy, much boys?

  4. tia April 26, 2013 at 12:40 am

    Are you 8oxer over at Dalrock’s? He (or she) is having a go at them over calling any and everything under the sun “Cultural Marxism”. Not a single one of them has even read one paragraph of Karl Marx but all of a sudden they are spouting their version of “Marxist Theory”!

    A bunch of uneducated fools.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Henry Dampier

On the outer right side of history

Bloody shovel

Don't call it a spade

The Better Man Project ™

a journey into the depths

Adventures in Red Pill Wifery

A First Officer's Log

Renard Moreau Presents

Cool Miscellaneous Thoughts

Kingdom of Introversion

The World according to the 'introvert' and the 'nerd'

There Is No Game

It is not the game that changes, it is only yourself.

Mike Cernovich Presents Danger & Play

For those who want more out of life.

insideawomansmind

An honest, uncensored woman's state of mind.

Stares at the World

The Kingdom of Heaven is spread out upon the Earth, and men see it not.

Captain Capitalism

Not essential to the faith

Krauser PUA

An international man of mystery

Free Northerner

Iron Sharpens Iron

The Spearhead

Piercing the Shield of Ignorance

Thumotic

A community for men with the fighting spirit

Society of Amateur Gentlemen

The True Inheritance of Western Culture

Owning Your Shit

Not essential to the faith

%d bloggers like this: